Hearth Record

Circle of Life Hospice and Palliative Care

A hospice in San Antonio, Texas 78249

4730 College Park, San Antonio, Texas 78249. (210) 890-2700.

CMS’s own record, on Care Compare

Watch and the shortlist are kept with a free account, on every device. Your watch list. CMS’s own record is on Care Compare.

The short answer

Record last released by CMS on Oct 23, 2026. We couldn’t read Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ list since Oct 27, 2026: qcor.cms.gov now refuses our reader. This record is as of then.

The last 24 months 3 deficiencies in 1 month of the last 36. Last cited Apr 2024. Most serious: Standard-level. Every month

Each figure’s source sits beside it, in its section below.

What these words mean2
Inspection (survey)
A visit by state inspectors, often unannounced, who check a place against the rules it must meet. For nursing homes and other places Medicare pays, CMS calls these visits surveys: a standard survey of a nursing home comes at least every 15 months, and a complaint survey whenever a complaint calls for one. Source: CMS; 42 CFR 488.308.
Deficiency, citation, violation
What inspectors write up when a place didn’t meet a rule: the rule, what they saw, and when. CMS calls it a deficiency; states may say citation or violation. It is the inspectors’ finding, not a court’s, and the place is usually asked for a plan to correct it. Source: CMS, statement of deficiencies (Form CMS-2567); each state’s licensing agency.

What did inspectors find?

3 deficiencies cited in the last three years

The middle of the 91 hospices serving ZIP code 78249 had 4.

The last inspection on record was on Apr 26, 2024: an initial inspection by the Community Health Accreditation Partner.

Source:

CMS, QCOR hospice inspection reports. Released Oct 23, 2026. Updated quarterly.

CMS, Hospice ZIP Data. Released Aug 26, 2026. Updated quarterly.

When those deficiencies happened

3 deficiencies in 1 month of the last 36. Last cited Apr 2024. Most serious: Standard-level. The last 3 years, to Oct 27, 2026.

3 deficiencies by month over the last 3 years. Each cell is one month.
JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
2023 NovDec
2024 JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
2025 JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
2026 JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOct

Hover or focus a month to read it.

No visit on record Visited, nothing cited A stronger orange is more serious, on its source’s own levels, read onto four bands: from the least serious it publishes to the most
Source:

Hearth Record drew this from the dates and levels in the source’s own records.

Each deficiency, as cited

Rule titles as CMS’s inspectors cite them, set in sentence case.

Source:

CMS, QCOR hospice inspection reports. Released Oct 23, 2026. Updated quarterly.

Apr 26, 2024: initial inspection by the Community Health Accreditation Partner3 deficiencies
  • Content of comprehensive assessment (42 CFR 418.54(c)(6)(i))

    The inspectors’ words, 381 words

    “It is required that the documented comprehensive assessment includes a drug profile that contains the patient’s current prescription and over-the-counter (OTC) drugs. The drug profile is updated per the hospice policy and procedure, but, at minimum, at the time of each comprehensive assessment and/or when new medication is added, or changes are made to existing medication. This standard was not met as evidenced by document review, interview, and observation. In 2 of 3 (67%) medication profiles for active hospice patients reviewed revealed that the hospice agency did not ensure that the patient’s drug profile contained the patient’s current prescription and over-the-counter drugs. The hospice agency did not ensure the patient’s drug profile was updated per the hospice policy and procedure. Agency Policy: HCL/PC.85, last reviewed: 100121, stated in part, the hospice will maintain a current, accurate list of all prescription and over the counter (OTC) medications taken by the patient. (Medication Profile) Home Visit 1: During home visit #1 with the aide (Personnel Record 8) on 04/25/2024, a review of the assisted living facility (ALF) medication profile was reviewed. The medication profile listed dicyclomine 20mg by mouth (PO) four times a day. The medication was ordered 03/06/2024. The hospice agency’s medication profile listed dicyclomine 20mg PO twice a day. The facility also listed gas relief 125 mg soft gel PO every four hours scheduled. The hospice agency listed gas relief 125 mg soft gel PO as needed. The facility had listed Lantus as 100 units/ml, giving 15 units subcutaneously daily at bedtime. The hospice had Lantus 10 units subcutaneously daily. Home Visit 2: During home visit #2 with the social worker (Personnel Record7) on 04/252024, the ALF medication profile was reviewed. The ALF medication profile listed acetaminophen 650 mg suppository rectally every four hours as needed, bisacodyl 10 mg suppository daily as needed, promethazine 25 mg by mouth every six hours as needed, and morphine sulfate 100mg/5ml, give 0.25 ml by mouth or sublingually every four hours as needed. The medications were ordered on 12/22/2023. Memantine Hcl 10 mg by mouth daily was ordered on 03/13/2023. None of these medications were listed on the hospice agency’s medication profile provided by the Director of Nursing on 04/24/2024. The Director of Nursing agreed that the medication profiles had not been reconciled on 04/25/2024.”

    Rule L0530. Standard-level.

  • Recruiting and retaining (42 CFR 418.78(c))

    The inspectors’ words, 152 words

    “It is required that the hospice documents and demonstrates viable and ongoing efforts to recruit and retain volunteers. This standard was not met as evidenced by interview and observation. In 1 of 1 (100%) volunteer program binder reviewed revealed that the hospice agency did not ensure that the Volunteer Coordinator documented viable and ongoing efforts to recruit and retain volunteers. During an interview, the Volunteer Coordinator stated she recruited volunteers at churches and colleges. The Volunteer Coordinator stated the program subscribed to volunteer match.com for recruitment. When asked how volunteers are retained, the Volunteer Coordinator explained that the agency gives small gifts of appreciation to volunteers for retention. The Volunteer Coordinator stated she did not know she needed to document the recruitment and retention efforts. The Director of Nursing was present during the telephone interview and agreed that there was no documented evidence of ongoing recruitment or retention of volunteers on 04/26/24.”

    Rule L0645. Standard-level.

  • Discharge or transfer of care (42 CFR 418.104(e)(2)(i))

    The inspectors’ words, 188 words

    “It is required that if a patient revokes the election of hospice care or is discharged from hospice per hospice regulation §418.26 (i.e., no longer terminally ill), the hospice forwards to the patient’s attending physician a copy of the hospice discharge summary. This standard was not met as evidenced by clinical record review, document review, and interview. In 1 of 2 (50%) clinical records reviewed for patients who were live discharges while on services revealed that the hospice did not ensure that a copy of the hospice discharge summary was forwarded to the attending physician. Agency Policy HCL/PE.35 Mcr., last reviewed: 100121, stated in part, the hospice will forward copies of the following information to the patient’s attending physician: hospice discharge summary and patients clinical record, if requested. Clinical Record 12: The patient revoked hospice on 06/28/2023. A documented discharge summary was completed on 06/28/2023. There was no documented evidence that the discharge summary was forwarded to the patient’s attending physician. During an interview on 04/26/2024, the Director of Nursing agreed that there was no documented evidence of the discharge summary being forwarded to the patient’s attending physician.”

    Rule L0683. Standard-level.

The one inspection in the last three years
Inspections on record
DateVisitWhat the record says
Apr 26, 2024Initial inspection by the Community Health Accreditation Partner3 deficiencies cited

Is it certified?

  • Medicare-certified hospice since Jun 18, 2021.
  • Ownership: for-profit.
  • No deficiency or on record in the last three years.
Source:

CMS, Hospice General Information. Released Aug 26, 2026. Updated quarterly.

CMS, QCOR hospice inspection reports. Released Oct 23, 2026. Updated quarterly.

Has anything been proven against it?

  • CMS doesn’t publish fines or other penalties for hospices, so none are shown.
  • 0 deficiencies cited in the last three years came from inspections that included a complaint investigation.
Source:

CMS, QCOR hospice inspection reports. Released Oct 23, 2026. Updated quarterly.

Who does the caring?

  • From Medicare claims (Jan 1, 2023 to Dec 31, 2024): 7.9 nurse care minutes per routine home care day, 6.4% of skilled nursing minutes at weekends and a visit near death for 86.8% of patients who died.
  • Where its patients were cared for (Jan 1, 2024 to Dec 31, 2024): 92% at home, 6% in assisted living, 2% in a nursing facility.
Source:

CMS, Hospice Provider Data. Released Aug 26, 2026. Updated quarterly.

Staffing measures
MeasureThis provider
Nurse care minutes per routine home care day7.9 min
Skilled nursing minutes at weekends6.4%
Visits near death86.8% of patients who died

Who owns it?

  • 8 owners or officers are people: Carmen E Benavides (owns 5% or more directly, 50%); Carmen E Benavides (limited partner, 50%); Carmen E Benavides (corporate officer, 50%); Carmen E Benavides (managing employee (on the payroll), 50%); Tobi Aguigui (owns 5% or more directly, 50%); Tobi Aguigui (limited partner, 50%); Tobi Aguigui (corporate officer, 50%); Tobi Aguigui (managing employee (on the payroll), 50%).
  • No private-equity firm among the owners CMS lists.
  • No real-estate investment trust among the owners CMS lists.
Source:

CMS, Hospice All Owners and Hospice Enrollments. Released Sep 29, 2026. Updated quarterly.

What do families say?

  • CMS gives no family caregiver survey rating: “The number of cases is too small to report Star Ratings.”
  • CMS’s Hospice Care Index: 7 of 10 (Jan 1, 2023 to Dec 31, 2024).
  • 91.74% of patients were assessed on all seven of CMS’s measures at the start of care (Oct 1, 2024 to Sep 30, 2025); 41.6% had visits from a nurse or social worker on at least 2 of their last 3 days (Jan 1, 2023 to Dec 31, 2024).
Source:

CMS, CAHPS Hospice Survey and Hospice Provider Data. Released Aug 26, 2026. Updated quarterly.

Ratings and measures, as published
MeasureRating
Family caregiver survey ratingCMS star rating from its survey of patients’ family caregivers, 1 to 5Not rated
Hospice Care IndexCMS’s Hospice Care Index, 0 to 10 (higher is better): a point for each of ten measures from Medicare claims on which the hospice meets CMS’s threshold7 of 10

How does it compare nearby?

  • Of the 91 hospices CMS’s data show serving patients in ZIP code 78249, where this hospice’s office is, the middle number of deficiencies cited in the last three years was 4; this one had 3.
Source:

CMS, Hospice ZIP Data. Released Aug 26, 2026. Updated quarterly.

CMS, QCOR hospice inspection reports. Released Oct 23, 2026. Updated quarterly.

What the record doesn’t say

  • CMS doesn’t publish fines or other penalties for hospices, so none are shown.
  • Only complaints that led to a citation appear; complaints that didn’t aren’t published.
  • CMS ended its Special Focus Program for hospices with serious problems on Feb 14, 2025, so no hospice is marked as one.
  • Hospice quality measures have a gap from October 2025: CMS replaced its patient assessment then, and public results from the new one (HOPE) are expected around November 2027.

Sources

If you believe something here is wrong, a correction starts with the agency whose record this copies: CMS. CMS’s own record is on Care Compare. If Hearth Record copied something wrongly, it will fix it and log the correction publicly, with its date: how corrections work.

Source:

This copy of the record was made on Oct 27, 2026.

From the hospice

The public record above comes first. Anything the hospice adds will appear here, below it, and say who wrote it.

Replies

None. Replies aren’t open yet. When they open, the hospice will be able to answer any finding for free, and the reply will show beside that finding, unedited and dated.

Paid listing

None. Paid listings aren’t open yet. When they open, anything paid for will say “Paid by the hospice”, and paying will never change a finding, a rating or the order of results.

How to read a record

Four things every record does, shown on an example record made up for this guide.

An example record, made up for this guide

An example nursing home

Made up for this guide: no real place is shown

Not fully inspected in over two years (CMS flag)

11 health citations at the latest inspection cycle

The state average is 14.3.

Source:

CMS, State and US Averages and Health Deficiencies. Released Oct 8, 2026. Updated monthly.

From the homeNone yet. Replies and paid listings aren’t open, and when they open they will sit here, below the record.

1 of 4

Every fact names its source.

Who published it, when, and how often it changes sit beside each fact, with a link to the agency’s own file.

Sign in

A free account keeps your watch list, shortlists, comparisons and saved searches on every device, and can email you when something you watch changes. Browsing never needs one.