Old Navy Recalls Stuffed Toys; Button Eyes Can Detach and Pose a Choking Hazard to Young Children
Kids’ product recall 09-134. Announced by CPSC on Feb 19, 2009.
Watch and the shortlist are kept with a free account, on every device. Your watch list. CPSC’s own notice is on cpsc.gov.
The short answer
Announced by CPSC on Feb 19, 2009. Copied from CPSC on Oct 24, 2026.
- About 35,500 in the United States and 5,400 in Canada units, as CPSC gives them
- None injuries, CPSC’s notice says
Every line below is in CPSC’s own words, with its source beside it.
What’s wrong with it?
The stuffed toys have two button eyes that could detach from the toy, posing a choking hazard to young children.
CPSC, Recalls API. Checked Oct 24, 2026. Updated daily.
What should you do?
Consumers should immediately take the recalled stuffed toy away from young children and return it to any Old Navy store for a full refund. If purchased online, contact Old Navy for instructions on returning the toy for a full refund. Consumers who return the toy before July 1, 2009 will also receive a $5 coupon toward a future Old Navy purchase.
CPSC, Recalls API. Checked Oct 24, 2026. Updated daily.
- How to reach the firm: For additional information, contact Old Navy toll-free at (866) 580-9930 between 9 a.m. and 9 p.m. ET Monday through Friday, or between 12 p.m. and 7 p.m. ET on Saturday, visit the firm’s Web site at www.oldnavy.com, or e-mail the firm at custserv@oldnavy.com
Which ones are recalled?
The stuffed animal and creature toys are made out of cotton and have plastic button eyes. They come in a variety of styles, such as a rabbit, penguin and reindeer. The recalled toys and style numbers are listed below: Type of Stuffed Toy Style Number Brown Plaid Creature (Stubby Stuberson) 612756 Pink Striped Dove 600571 Gray Dog 600572 Hot Pink Creature (Lucy Toothy) 612800 White Dog (Dr. Poopsie) 612738 Brown Penguin 612672 Light Pink Rabbit 612671 Brown Reindeer 612728 Dark Pink Rabbit (Honey O’Bunny) 612806 The style number is located on a white label sewn into the side seam of the toy.
About 35,500 in the United States and 5,400 in Canada units, as CPSC gives them.
Stuffed Animal and Creature Toys.
CPSC, Recalls API. Checked Oct 24, 2026. Updated daily.
CPSC’s photos
CPSC shows 1 photo on its notice. Hearth Record doesn’t copy them; each opens on cpsc.gov.
Who made and sold it?
- Distributed by Old Navy LLC, San Francisco, Calif.
- Old Navy stores and on the Web at www.oldnavy.com from July 2008 through February 2009 for between $6 and $10.
- Made in China, as the notice gives it.
CPSC, Recalls API. Checked Oct 24, 2026. Updated daily.
Was anyone hurt?
None reported.
CPSC, Recalls API. Checked Oct 24, 2026. Updated daily.
What the record doesn’t say
- The notice lists no UPCs, so check the model, the description and the photos.
- The notice lists no model numbers in a field of their own; its description may give them.
- How many have been returned or fixed isn’t in the notice.
Hearth Record wrote these lines.
Sources
-
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, Recalls API.
Checked Oct 24, 2026. Updated daily. Public domain (U.S. Government work). CPSC asks to be credited, and that no endorsement be implied.
Recalls of kids’ and home products are from the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC). CPSC does not endorse Hearth Record. Copied on Oct 24, 2026.