Hearth Record

Gentle Hands Care Agency,llc the

A home health agency in Columbus, Ohio 43205

1487 Madison Avenue, Columbus, Ohio 43205. (614) 252-5224.

CMS’s own record, on Care Compare

Watch and the shortlist are kept with a free account, on every device. Your watch list. CMS’s own record is on Care Compare.

The short answer

Record last released by CMS on Oct 21, 2026.

The last 24 months 7 deficiencies in 1 month of the last 36. Last cited Feb 2024. Most serious: Condition-level. Every month

Each figure’s source sits beside it, in its section below.

What these words mean3
Inspection (survey)
A visit by state inspectors, often unannounced, who check a place against the rules it must meet. For nursing homes and other places Medicare pays, CMS calls these visits surveys: a standard survey of a nursing home comes at least every 15 months, and a complaint survey whenever a complaint calls for one. Source: CMS; 42 CFR 488.308.
Deficiency, citation, violation
What inspectors write up when a place didn’t meet a rule: the rule, what they saw, and when. CMS calls it a deficiency; states may say citation or violation. It is the inspectors’ finding, not a court’s, and the place is usually asked for a plan to correct it. Source: CMS, statement of deficiencies (Form CMS-2567); each state’s licensing agency.
Condition-level deficiency
For hospices, home health agencies, hospitals and dialysis facilities, CMS writes deficiencies at two levels. Standard is the usual one; condition-level is the more serious, when a problem is serious enough that the provider doesn’t meet a whole condition of taking part in Medicare. Source: CMS, State Operations Manual.

What did inspectors find?

The last inspection on record was on Feb 7, 2024: a complaint inspection.

7 deficiencies cited in the last three years, 2 of them at condition level, the most serious.

2 deficiencies at condition level, the more serious of CMS’s two levels

Source:

CMS, QCOR home health inspection reports. Released Oct 20, 2026. Updated monthly.

When those deficiencies happened

7 deficiencies in 1 month of the last 36. Last cited Feb 2024. Most serious: Condition-level. The last 3 years, to Oct 24, 2026.

7 deficiencies by month over the last 3 years. Each cell is one month.
JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
2023 NovDec
2024 JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
2025 JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
2026 JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOct

Hover or focus a month to read it.

No visit on record Visited, nothing cited A stronger orange is more serious, on its source’s own levels, read onto four bands: from the least serious it publishes to the most
Source:

Hearth Record drew this from the dates and levels in the source’s own records.

Each deficiency, as cited

Rule titles as CMS’s inspectors cite them, set in sentence case.

Source:

CMS, QCOR home health inspection reports. Released Oct 20, 2026. Updated monthly.

Feb 7, 2024: complaint inspection7 deficiencies
  • Comprehensive Assessment Of Patients

    The inspectors’ words, 132 words

    “Comprehensive Assessment of Patients CFR(s): 484.55 Condition of participation: Comprehensive assessment of patients. Each patient must receive, and an HHA must provide, a patient-specific, comprehensive assessment. For Medicare beneficiaries, the HHA must verify the patient’s eligibility for the Medicare home health benefit including homebound status, both at the time of the initial assessment visit and at the time of the comprehensive assessment. This Condition is not met as evidenced by: Based on medical record review and staff interview, the agency failed to have the initial assessment completed by a Registered Nurse (G514) and failed to complete the comprehensive assessment with in five calendar days after the start of care (G520). The cumulative effects of these systemic problems resulted in the agency’s inability to ensure the patient’s assessed needs would be met. .”

    Rule G0510. Condition-level. From a complaint.

  • Care Planning, Coordination, Quality Of Care

    The inspectors’ words, 271 words

    “Care planning, coordination, quality of care CFR(s): 484.60 Condition of participation: Care planning, coordination of services, and quality of care. Patients are accepted for treatment on the reasonable expectation that an HHA can meet the patient’s medical, nursing, rehabilitative, and social needs in his or her place of residence. Each patient must receive an individualized written plan of care, including any revisions or additions. The individualized plan of care must specify the care and services necessary to meet the patient-specific needs as identified in the comprehensive assessment, including identification of the responsible discipline(s), and the measurable outcomes that the HHA anticipates will occur as a result of implementing and coordinating the plan of care. The individualized plan of care must also specify the patient and caregiver education and training. Services must be furnished in accordance with accepted standards of practice. This Condition is not met as evidenced by: Based on medical record review and staff interview, the facility failed to have a written plan of care (G572) and a plan of care only as ordered by a physician (G580). The cumulative effects of these systemic practices resulted in the agency’s inability to ensure patient care would be provided as ordered by the physician on an individualized basis. Based on document review and staff interview the facility failed to have a written Plan of Care G-572, A Plan of Care that conforms to the Physician Orders G578, a plan of care only as ordered by a physician G-580. The cumulative effects of these systemic problems resulted in the Home Health Agency inability to ensure a physician ordered plan of care was developed.”

    Rule G0570. Condition-level. From a complaint.

  • Plan Of Care

    The inspectors’ words, 205 words

    “Plan of care CFR(s): 484.60(a)(1) Each patient must receive the home health services that are written in an individualized plan of care that identifies patient-specific measurable outcomes and goals, and which is established, periodically reviewed, and signed by a doctor of medicine, osteopathy, or podiatry acting within the scope of his or her state license, certification, or registration. If a physician or allowed practitioner refers a patient under a plan of care that cannot be completed until after an evaluation visit, the physician or allowed practitioner is consulted to approve additions or modifications to the original plan. This Standard is not met as evidenced by: Based on medical record review and staff interview, the agency failed to have a written plan of care. This affected two (Pt #1 and Pt #3) of the four records reviewed. Census at the time of survey was 26. 1) The medical record review for Pt #1 failed to reveal a written plan of care had been developed. 2) The medical record review for Pt #3 failed to reveal a written plan of care had been developed. Interview with Staff A on 02/07/24 at 11:30 AM verified the agency did not have a written plans of care for these patients.”

    Rule G0572. Standard-level. From a complaint.

  • Hha Can No Longer Meet The Patient’S Needs

    The inspectors’ words, 351 words

    “HHA can no longer meet the patient’s needs CFR(s): 484.50(d)(1) The transfer or discharge is necessary for the patient’s welfare because the HHA and the physician or allowed practitioner, who is responsible for the home health plan of care agree that the HHA can no longer meet the patient’s needs, based on the patient’s acuity. The HHA must arrange a safe and appropriate transfer to other care entities when the needs of the patient exceed the HHA’s capabilities; This Element is not met as evidenced by: Based on medical record review, review of a current census, review of a 30 day notice to stop services, and staff interview, the agency failed to properly advise the client and/or physician of the discharge. This affected two, Pt #1 and Pt #3, of the four patients reviewed. Census at the time of survey was 26. 1) Review of the medical record for Pt #1 revealed no documentation related to any discharge and no documentation the physician was notified of a discharge. Pt. #1 was not currently on the census. Interview with Staff A on 02/07/24 at 11:30 AM revealed the agency did not have sufficient staffing to cover the shifts for PT #1. Staff A further stated the agency had attempted to discharge the client in October of 2023 and had given a 30 day notice. Staff A stated the case manager had requested the agency to continue services as they had not been able to find another agency to accept the client. Staff A stated the agency did continue services as able through 01/20/24. . 2) Review of the medical record for Pt #3 revealed no documentation the physician was notified and involved in a discharge. The patient was not on the current census. Review of a discharge notice dated 09/07/23 revealed Pt #3 was provided a 30 day notice of stop of services due to a lack of employees. The end date with the agency would be 10/07/23. Interview with Staff A on 02/07/24 at 11:30 AM revealed the agency did not have sufficient staffing to cover the shifts for PT #3.”

    Rule G0454. Element-level. From a complaint.

  • Rn Performs Assessment

    The inspectors’ words, 196 words

    “RN performs assessment CFR(s): 484.55(a)(1) A registered nurse must conduct an initial assessment visit to determine the immediate care and support needs of the patient; and, for Medicare patients, to determine eligibility for the Medicare home health benefit, including homebound status. The initial assessment visit must be held either within 48 hours of referral, or within 48 hours of the patient’s return home, or on the physician or allowed practitioner - ordered start of care date. This Element is not met as evidenced by: Based on medical record review and staff interview, the agency failed have initial assessments completed by a Registered Nurse (RN). This affected two (Pt #1 and Pt #3) patients the four records reviewed. Census at the time of survey was 26. The medical record review for Pt #1 failed to reveal an initial assessment was done by a RN. The medical record review for Pt #3 failed to reveal an initial assessment was done by a RN Interview with Staff A on 02/07/24 at 11:30 AM revealed the agency did not have a RN to be able to perform the initial assessment. The agency opened the cases without the assessments being done.”

    Rule G0514. Element-level. From a complaint.

  • 5 Calendar Days After Start Of Care

    The inspectors’ words, 200 words

    “5 calendar days after start of care CFR(s): 484.55(b)(1) The comprehensive assessment must be completed in a timely manner, consistent with the patient’s immediate needs, but no later than 5 calendar days after the start of care. This Element is not met as evidenced by: Based on medical record review and staff interview, the agency failed to complete comprehensive assessment within the five days after the start of care. This affected two (Pt #1 and Pt #3) patients of four patients reviewed. Census at the time of survey was 26. 1) The medical record review for Pt #1 failed to reveal a comprehensive assessment was completed within five days of the start of care. 2) The medical record review for Pt #3 failed to reveal a comprehensive assessment was completed within five days of the start of care. Interview with Staff A on 02/07/24 at 11:30 AM revealed the agency did not have a Registered Nurse to be able to perform the initial assessment. As the initial assessments were not done the complete comprehensive assessments were not completed within the five days after the start of care. Staff A stated the agency opened the cases without the assessments being done.”

    Rule G0520. Element-level. From a complaint.

  • Only As Ordered By A Physician

    The inspectors’ words, 134 words

    “Only as ordered by a physician CFR(s): 484.60(b)(1) Drugs, services, and treatments are administered only as ordered by a physician or allowed practitioner. This Element is not met as evidenced by: Based on medical record review and staff interview, the agency failed to have physician orders for services provided. This affected two (Pt #1 and Pt #3) of the four records reviewed. Census at the time of survey was 26. 1) The medical record review for Pt #1 failed to reveal physician orders for services provided. 2) he medical record review for Pt #3 failed to reveal physician orders for services provided. Interview with Staff A on 02/07/24 at 11:30 AM verified the agency never contacted a physician to obtain orders for the services being provided. The agency opened the cases without physician orders.”

    Rule G0580. Element-level. From a complaint.

The one inspection in the last three years
Inspections on record
DateVisitWhat the record says
Feb 7, 2024Complaint inspection7 deficiencies cited

Is it certified?

  • Medicare-certified home health agency since Nov 14, 2015.
  • Ownership: proprietary (for profit).
  • Cited at in the last three years: it didn’t meet a whole condition of Medicare’s rules.
Source:

CMS, Home Health Care Agencies. Released Oct 21, 2026. Updated quarterly.

CMS, QCOR home health inspection reports. Released Oct 20, 2026. Updated monthly.

Has anything been proven against it?

  • CMS doesn’t publish fines or other penalties for home health agencies, so none are shown.
  • 7 deficiencies cited in the last three years came from inspections that included a complaint investigation.
Source:

CMS, QCOR home health inspection reports. Released Oct 20, 2026. Updated monthly.

Who does the caring?

  • Offers nursing care, physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech pathology and home health aide services.
  • Doesn’t offer medical social services.
  • CMS doesn’t publish staffing levels for home health agencies.
Source:

CMS, Home Health Care Agencies. Released Oct 21, 2026. Updated quarterly.

Who owns it?

  • 5 owners or officers are people: Paul David Howard (owns 5% or more directly, 100%); Paul David Howard (corporate director, 100%); Paul David Howard (runs it (operational or managerial control), 100%); Kimberly Neal (managing employee (on the payroll)); Kimberly Neal (runs it (operational or managerial control)).
  • No private-equity firm among the owners CMS lists.
  • No real-estate investment trust among the owners CMS lists.
Source:

CMS, Home Health Agency All Owners and Home Health Agency Enrollments. Released Sep 29, 2026. Updated quarterly.

How do patients fare?

  • CMS gives no : “The number of patient episodes for this measure is too small to report.”
  • CMS gives no : “No survey results are available for this period.”
Source:

CMS, Home Health Care Agencies and Home Health Patient Survey. Released Oct 21, 2026. Updated quarterly.

Ratings and measures, as published
MeasureRating
Quality of patient care ratingCMS star rating, 1 to 5 in half starsNot rated
Patient survey ratingCMS star rating from its survey of the agency’s patients, 1 to 5Not rated

How does it compare nearby?

  • CMS gives this agency no quality of patient care rating to compare.
Source:

CMS, Home Health ZIP Codes and Home Health Care Agencies. Released Oct 21, 2026. Updated quarterly.

What the record doesn’t say

  • CMS doesn’t publish fines or other penalties for home health agencies, so none are shown.
  • Only complaints that led to a citation appear; complaints that didn’t aren’t published.
  • QCOR says some of its home health reports are accurate or available only through May 19, 2021, because of a systems migration.
  • Many home health agencies are inspected by a private accrediting organisation instead of the state, and QCOR’s home health file doesn’t appear to include those inspections: no inspection on record here doesn’t mean none took place.

Sources

If you believe something here is wrong, a correction starts with the agency whose record this copies: CMS. CMS’s own record is on Care Compare. If Hearth Record copied something wrongly, it will fix it and log the correction publicly, with its date: how corrections work.

Source:

This copy of the record was made on Oct 24, 2026.

From the agency

The public record above comes first. Anything the agency adds will appear here, below it, and say who wrote it.

Replies

None. Replies aren’t open yet. When they open, the agency will be able to answer any finding for free, and the reply will show beside that finding, unedited and dated.

Paid listing

None. Paid listings aren’t open yet. When they open, anything paid for will say “Paid by the agency”, and paying will never change a finding, a rating or the order of results.

How to read a record

Four things every record does, shown on an example record made up for this guide.

An example record, made up for this guide

An example nursing home

Made up for this guide: no real place is shown

Not fully inspected in over two years (CMS flag)

11 health citations at the latest inspection cycle

The state average is 14.3.

Source:

CMS, State and US Averages and Health Deficiencies. Released Oct 28, 2026. Updated monthly.

From the homeNone yet. Replies and paid listings aren’t open, and when they open they will sit here, below the record.

1 of 4

Every fact names its source.

Who published it, when, and how often it changes sit beside each fact, with a link to the agency’s own file.

Sign in

A free account keeps your watch list, shortlists, comparisons and saved searches on every device, and can email you when something you watch changes. Browsing never needs one.